|
There are many theoretical benefits to be gained from having
a politician attend a charity event. Politicians are high
profile figures, on a national or local level, and their
presence automatically makes it more likely that an event
will attract press coverage.
But how easy is it to find politicians willing to support
your cause or attend such events? And what can you or the
politician expect to happen afterwards?
Politicians are not generally held in high esteem by the
public, and if you asked senior managers in the third sector
to draw lists of problem groups with whom they had to deal,
politicians would certainly feature. Yet the overwhelming
response from charities approached during the writing of
this article was that most politicians do everything they
can to support a wide variety of good causes, and that their
presence at an event does raise its profile significantly.
The experience of the Addenbrooke’s Charitable Trust
(ACT), which raises funds for Addenbrooke’s Hospital
in Cambridge, is typical. The Trust has been able to call
on the support of local MPs including Andrew Lansley, Conservative
MP for South Cambridgeshire, the constituency in which the
hospital is based, who arranged for the charity to run an
event on the River Terrace at the House of Commons in 2006
to promote itself to corporate entities.
“The risk always with politicians is that they get
a better offer,” says Keith Day, chief executive of
the Addenbrooke’s Charitable Trust, and also a former
executive director of the NHS Foundation Trust that runs
the hospital. “I’m not being disrespectful,
and I don’t wish to appear too cynical when I say
this, but politicians have to seize opportunities as they
come along. I faced exactly the same problem when I was
working for the hospital and we tried to get politicians
to come and see us or attend events. There’s always
that risk that they may have to disappear at the last minute.”
Of course, it is generally true that local politicians are
less likely to be called away on urgent business than more
senior members of the government, and in any case, few charities
seem to have suffered from sudden cancellations. “Usually
they turn up when they say they will,” says Rowan
Harvey, parliamentary and campaigns officer at the Terrence
Higgins Trust. “It really just depends on how busy
the individual politician is, and who deals with their diary.”
But contacting a local MP is not an obvious first step for
every charity. Instead, they would be well-advised to do
some research to try and find MPs with interests that suggest
they might be sympathetic towards the charity’s cause.
Relevant all-party parliamentary groups, which focus on
all sorts of different causes and interest groups, are a
good place to start.
For example, the Terrence Higgins Trust has fruitful working
relationships with members of the all-party parliamentary
groups on AIDS and on Pro-Choice and Sexual Health. Websites
such as theyworkforyou.com, which details members’
interests and voting records, can also be useful resources.
There are also a limited number of opportunities to approach
politicians directly on their own patch. The mental health
charity Rethink has benefited from MPs and peers hosting
dinners in the Houses of Parliament, at which Rethink representatives
have been allowed to make speeches.
“You can’t actually fundraise at them –
parliamentary rules forbid it – so it’s really
about building relationships, and getting people to think
about issues,” explains Paul Corry, director of public
affairs at Rethink. “But it gives everybody the opportunity
to talk about mental health in general, or about specific
issues.” Invited audiences at these dinners may also
include academics or representatives of industry, as well
as politicians.
Charities can also enter a lottery for the chance to have
a display promoting their work in the Houses of Parliament.
WaterAid won the chance to do so in 2006. “We had
banners up, and interactive displays, and then we invited
particular MPs we wanted to engage with to meet us there,”
says Jennean Alkadiri, campaigns manager at Water Aid. “We
also asked supporters to contact their local MPs and arrange
to meet them at the display. It’s easy for the MPs,
they are in the corridors walking around, and it’s
just five minutes out of their day. We wouldn’t have
been able to meet so many any other way.”
Top
National charities like the Campaign to Protect Rural England
(CPRE) can also use their membership to lobby MPs. “It
is easier if you are a national organisation with people
who are active at the ground level, and active in MPs’
constituencies,” says Ben Stafford, head of campaigns
at the CPRE. “That will give you another route in,
if you have people writing letters.”
In some circumstances MPs may also be prepared to table
Ten Minute Rule Bills or Early Day Motions to help highlight
issues important to a charity they support.
In May this year John Penrose, Conservative MP for Weston-Super-Mare,
sponsored a Ten Minute Rule Bill on Rural Tranquillity,
in support of the CPRE’s campaign for tranquillity
to be taken into account in planning policy.
Earlier in the year WaterAid and TearFund worked with Bill
Cash, Conservative MP for Stone on an Early Day Motion based
on the charity’s End Water Poverty Campaign. Following
lobbying from Bill Cash and other supportive politicians,
and a national letter-writing campaign by WaterAid supporters
targeting their local MPs, 226 MPs eventually signed the
motion. A Westminster Hall Debate then followed, at which
the then Secretary of State for International Development,
Hilary Benn, responded on behalf of the government.
It seems, in fact, that the negative side-effects of working
with MPs are mostly theoretical. Much as one would like
to dish some dirt, it is difficult to come up with an example
of a charity suffering from any problems as a result of
its association with a politician. Of course, it is still
important to do everything possible to minimise the risk
of such a situation.
“There has to be an understanding that as an impartial
NGO you can be critical,” says the CPRE‘s Stafford.
“We are an independent organisation, and not in the
pockets of any political party. You need to make sure that
there is an honest understanding of the relationship on
both sides.”
Rethink’s Corry makes a similar point: “You
need to make it very clear that while your interests are
converging on this particular issue, the charity isn’t
going to promote the party or personal political interests
of the MP or peer; and that they shouldn’t use your
platform to express party political views.”
As long as both parties follow those rules, there is no
reason why even very close engagement with individual politicians,
who have courted controversy in their careers or personal
lives, should not be successful. Last September the Motor
Neurone Disease Association (MNDA) appointed Lembit Opik,
Liberal Democrat MP for Monmouth (and shadow secretary of
state for business, enterprise and regulatory reform) as
its president at its annual AGM. He has been involved with
the charity since his father’s death from Motor Neurone
Disease in 2005.
And his work is much appreciated at the MNDA. “He’s
been amazing for us in terms of what he’s achieved,”
says Mel Barry, a spokesperson for the Association. “He’s
got us access to cabinet ministers, meetings with Tony Blair
and now with Gordon Brown.
He’s been instrumental in leading our campaigns, and
he’s certainly raised our profile with other parliamentarians.
It’s probably fair to say that some of the things
that have happened wouldn’t have happened so fast
without him.”
She dismisses completely the idea that the charity could
have suffered in any way as a result of newspaper coverage
of Opik’s relationship with a pop star some years
his junior. As she points out, there isn’t really
much of a scandal to report on that anyway. “Our experience
has just been really positive,” says Barry. “Lembit
has really pushed us forward. He just brings so much energy,
and he has that human touch; people can relate to him.”
Even former politicians whose public image has been dragged
unceremoniously through the mire can be valuable as high
profile supporters. Lady Mary Archer is a trustee at Addenbrooke’s
Charitable Trust. Her husband Lord Archer, who needs no
introduction, has worked as an auctioneer for the charity
at fundraising events – as he continues to do for
many good causes – and Lord and Lady Archer also let
the Trust use their garden each summer for an evening garden
party.
I ask Keith Day if this association has ever had any kind
of negative effect on the charity. “Inevitably, you
will run across somebody who makes some adverse comment
about Lord and Lady Archer,” he concedes. “But
that is outweighed a hundred, or a thousand times by the
positive reactions to their involvement, and by their commitment
to us.”
Further information
Useful websites for finding out about MPs’ and peers’
interests and activities:
www.parliament.uk
www.theyworkforyou.com
Register of all-party parliamentary groups:
www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm/cmallparty/register/memi01.htm
Charities interested in mounting a display at the House
of Commons should contact the Sergeant of Arms Events Team
at the House of Commons (main switchboard 020 7219 3000),
who will be able to explain the procedure in full.
They will need to persuade an MP to write to a relevant
minister on their behalf to get their written approval and
then complete a Ballot Application. This will need to be
approved by Committee before the application is entered
into the ballot.
Top
To return to the September 07 features list click
here
|